Rogue splitting up

and with 3 good players and 3 subpar rogue totally diminated na in 2017 yea sounds about right....

not really, rogue players are one of the very best in their roles

yes KnoxXx is average: https://youtu.be/YOt1zzvt79g?t=14m22s
the only problem with current rouge is that they don't really adapt to changes, their teamwork and mechanics are the reason why they completely dominated NA in the first half of 2017, doubt it could happen without everyone on the team contributing as much as they did.

according to wolf soon and unkoe got picked up by immortals

Knoxxx is better or at least on par with some winstons in overwatch league such as Cwoosh, Muma, Super, Numlocked and xQc. He never got "carried" by Soon Unkoe and AKM, during the triple dps meta he was the solo tank and still performed incredibly well. Also, knoxxx used to play lucio at the pro level on Rogue before the roster changes.

KnOxXx is 1 of the best shotcalling lucios tbh and this is his main role.

he is one of the very best winstons he is not average

Keep in mind that Knoxxx most of the time played with 3 dps, and a zen, and when they do run D.va, AKM and Nico are sub par at least at early stages, lately Nico has been stepping it up. But my point is if you compare Knoxxx to Miro for example, Knoxxx has 3 dps and a zen while Miro has the best Ana in the world in his back pocket, at least before zen became a must pick, and one of the best off tanks by his side. Lunatic Hai allows Miro to make more flashy plays, is he bad/overrated? No, of course not, but keep in mind Knoxxx had much less resources to do his job, yet we almost never see him die early or overextend or get picked off, or have bad bubble placement, his engages are clean and he makes tons of room for his dps to do their jobs, it's just ignorant to assume Rouge were just carried by their dps, it's a team game, you simpily can't say a team that has been #1 in NA for months have 1/2 a team who is bad, that's just not how it works, are there better main tank players? Yeah, sure, but calling him subpar is just a mistake. I saw a game uploaded by Harbleu where MYKL, Babybay, and Nomy failed to take the first point, hell, even the first tick, on Volskya, even though the defense had no healers. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=29mOWEyI-lo&t=4s) Is it fair to call MYKL Babybay and Nomy bad? Well, MYKL maybe, statistically he's one of the worst Tracer players in the pro scene, but Babybay and Nomy are on an OWL team, it doesn't matter how good 2-3 members of your team are, if the rest can't do their jobs. Yeah, it's solo queue, but it still applys to the pro scene, a team with only 3 OWL worth members can't be dominant for months only through mechanical skill.

To add onto my earlier post, Overwatch is a team game with many moving, complicated parts. Tanks create space for DPS players to be able to eliminate players, Healers heal those tanks so they can do their job, DPS and Tanks peal for Supports so they can do their jobs. If one of the role's isn't executed properly, the whole dynamic falls apart. This is what we see from teams like Eunited and Renegades, who's tank role isn't fulfilled properly, meaning players like Mangachu and Unfixed aren't comfortable on the Tank role, and therefore don't do their jobs, so the DPS don't have space to make plays, and Support's don't have as much pealing. (You could apply this to Rouge, however, they were playing from hotels and what not in Canada and they actually preformed well near the end of Contenders season 1). The reason AKM, Soon, and Nico are able to do their jobs is because Knoxxx does his job and makes space, the reason that they were so successful for months is because everyone did their job well, not because AKM and Soon have good aim, well that was a part, but it is much more complex then that.